Italian Grocery Store - Lakeland FL

When I first started Alzaytoon three years ago, my focus was simple: bring the authentic Tunisian olive oil flavors I grew up with to Central Florida. What I didn't expect was how this journey would naturally lead me to expand into carefully selected Italian specialty foods, including premium Italian olive oils, that complement our core mission of authentic, quality imports.

After years of working with Italian suppliers in the Modena region for our award-winning balsamic vinegars, I've developed strong relationships that allow me to source genuine Italian specialty foods that you simply won't find in typical grocery stores. These connections, built through trust and shared commitment to quality, have opened doors to authentic products—from exceptional Italian olive oils to traditional specialties—that represent true Italian craftsmanship.

Through my established network of Italian suppliers, I've been able to curate a selection of genuine Italian specialty foods that haven't been watered down or processed beyond recognition. From premium Italian olive oils and hand-selected pasta varieties to traditional herb blends, pickled specialties, and artisanal oils, every product reflects the same commitment to authenticity that has made Alzaytoon a trusted presence throughout Winter Haven, Plant City, and the greater Central Florida region.

My Italian grocery selection isn't just about convenience – it's about bringing you the flavors that Italian families have treasured for generations, right here in Lakeland. Each product is something I would use in my own kitchen, chosen for its quality and authentic character.

Premium Italian Pasta & Grain Products

At Alzaytoon, our Italian pasta selection goes far beyond what you'll find on typical grocery store shelves. I source authentic angel hair, linguine, and fettuccine varieties directly from Italian producers who still follow traditional methods. These aren't mass-produced pastas – they're crafted with the same attention to detail that Italian families have valued for centuries. The texture, flavor, and cooking quality make a noticeable difference in every dish you create.

Authentic Italian Herbs & Seasonings

Our mixed Italian herb blends combine rosemary, thyme, basil, garlic, and crushed pepper in proportions that reflect traditional Italian cooking. Rather than settling for pre-packaged seasonings that lose their potency sitting on warehouse shelves, I work with suppliers who understand that fresh, properly dried herbs are essential for authentic Italian flavors. These blends bring the same aromatic qualities you'd experience in an Italian kitchen.

Specialty Italian Oils & Vinegars

Building on our authentic Italian olive oil and exceptional balsamic vinegars, our specialty collection includes premium avocado, grapeseed, sesame, and walnut oils selected for their quality and versatility. Our white and dark balsamic vinegars maintain the same standards that have earned our products international recognition alongside our award-winning Italian olive oils. Additionally, we offer Italian vinaigrettes, dipping blends, and marinades that showcase these premium Mediterranean ingredients.

Italian Tomato Products & Preserves

From rich tomato sauces to concentrated pastes and sun-dried tomatoes, our Italian tomato selection emphasizes the deep, complex flavors that make Italian cuisine distinctive. These products are sourced from regions known for their tomato-growing expertise, ensuring that each jar or can delivers the authentic taste that forms the foundation of so many Italian dishes.

Gourmet Italian Specialties & Condiments

Our Italian specialty collection extends beyond basic ingredients to include carefully selected stuffed olives, pickled peppers, and pickled mushrooms that add authentic Mediterranean flavors to your meals. These aren't typical grocery store varieties – they're sourced from Italian producers who maintain traditional preparation methods. We also carry unique balsamic-based sauces including hot, BBQ, and soy varieties that blend Italian craftsmanship with diverse flavor profiles.

Local Availability & Tasting Experience

Located at 231 N. Tennessee Ave. in Lakeland, our store offers hands-on tasting experiences where you can sample these Italian specialties before purchasing. No appointments are necessary – simply visit during our regular hours to explore flavors and find products that match your preferences. This personal approach ensures you're confident in your selections and can discover new favorites you might not have tried otherwise.

Proven Quality & Community Presence

The same commitment to authenticity that has earned our olive oils international gold medals – including recognition from the Los Angeles International EVOO Competition and London IOOC – guides our Italian product selection. You'll find us regularly at the Lakeland Farmers Market, Winter Park Farmers Market, and throughout Central Florida, where we've built relationships with customers who appreciate genuine imported foods over mass-market alternatives.

Central Florida Service Area

We proudly serve customers throughout Central Florida, including Winter Haven, Plant City, Highland City, Bartow, Kissimmee, Orlando, Port Saint Lucie, Fort Pierce, and The Villages. Whether you visit our Lakeland location or find us at one of our regular farmers market appearances, you'll experience the same dedication to quality and authenticity that defines everything we do.

Experience Authentic Italian Flavors Today

Ready to elevate your cooking with genuine Italian specialty foods? Visit our Lakeland store at 231 N. Tennessee Ave. for personalized guidance and complimentary tastings of our complete Italian collection. Our hands-on approach ensures you find exactly what you're looking for, whether you're recreating a family recipe or exploring new flavors.

Visit Our Store: Stop by our Lakeland location for personalized guidance and tasting experiences with our complete Italian specialty collection. No appointments necessary – we're here to help you discover authentic flavors.

Visit Our Markets: Find us at rotating farmers markets throughout Central Florida including Lakeland Farmers Market, Winter Park, and Fort Pierce for hands-on tasting and immediate purchase options.

Service Area Coverage: We proudly serve customers throughout Central Florida, from Winter Haven and Plant City to Orlando, Kissimmee, and The Villages. Quality Italian imports are now accessible throughout the region.

Contact Information

  • Location: 231 N Tennessee Ave, Lakeland, FL 33801
  • Phone Number: (407) 738-1022
  • Service Area: Central Florida (Lakeland, Winter Haven, Plant City, Orlando, Kissimmee, The Villages, Port Saint Lucie, Fort Pierce)
  • Market Schedule: Available at multiple Central Florida farmers markets weekly
  • Experience: 15+ years of olive wood kitchenware expertise